OverTraders.com takes a look through the fascinating and often tumultuous history of music distribution. We follow its development from tempestuous history steeped in piracy to the booming, legal business we know now. It’s a classic tale of disruption, litigation, and eventually, acceptance. So get ready and prepare to be dazzled!
Understanding Music Piracy
To truly grasp the evolution of music sharing, one must first understand what music piracy entails and how it all began. We’ll take that as unapproved. When music is duplicated and shared illegally, the creative workforce misses out on the revenue they earned through their hard work and creativity.
Definition of Music Piracy
In reality, music piracy is stealing. It involves reproducing, distributing, or using copyrighted music without the permission of the copyright holder, which is usually the artist, record label, or publisher. This can range from pirating their album by illegally downloading a song to sharing their entire discography on file-sharing platforms or worse, stream-ripping. British Performing Right Society (PRS) and Incopro found that the use of stream-ripping software jumped an incredible 67% in the UK alone. From 2016 to 2019, that program’s usage soared 1390%. In 2019, nearly a quarter (23%) of those surveyed said they used stream-ripping services. This staggering figure is derived from the IFPI’s (International Federation of the Phonographic Industry) annual Global Music Report. This illicit behavior cheats creators out of their pay and threatens the sustainability of the entire music community.
Historical Context
Before the internet, music piracy was restricted to real world copies – ie bootlegged cassettes or cds. Then came the digital revolution, which turned that calculus on its head. The internet and file-sharing technologies exploded in popularity. In doing so, they made copying and distributing music on a massive scale unimaginably easy. This new ease of access resulted in a catastrophic boom in online music piracy, with companies like Napster spearheading the way. This move from physical to digital content created a perfect storm for piracy. The ease and immediacy of online sharing quickly exceeded any prior form of piracy or infringement.
The Rise and Fall of Napster
In other words, Napster was a tremendous game-changer, moonshot, disruptive force that took the music industry and threw it into chaos. This service was the first consumer P2P killer app. Most importantly, it made it super easy for users to share MP3 files with one another. At their most popular, Napster had accumulated over 80 million active users per month. It created an enormous catalog of music in which anyone could download whatever they wanted for free.
Napster's Influence on the Industry
In the process, Napster proved the extraordinary appetite for digital music and showed the power of online distribution. More than anything, it showed how broken the traditional music industry model was. This model focused largely on physical sales and did not offer consumers a convenient option to purchase music online. Napster found itself in a series of doomed legal battles and went under. It did perhaps set the stage for all digital music services that followed by proving demand – i.e. that people indeed wanted to consume music online. The service showed the world there was a huge pent up demand for digital music. We need to do it in legal and sustainable ways.
Legal Battles and Consequences
The free-for-all approach of Napster was never going to be accepted by a highly monopolized music industry. Artists and record labels watched their lives’ works disappear as everyone began using the site to listen to music for free. Metallica, the thrash metal band, famously sued Napster after discovering their song "I Disappear" circulating on the platform before its official release. This lawsuit, with others, resulted in Napster’s eventual shutdown in 2001. Through those legal battles, it became evident that copyright protection was more important than ever in the digital age. They created the conditions for the emergence of legal online music services.
Effects of Piracy on Independent Artists
Only the largest of record labels have the resources to weather the piracy storm. Independent artists are in many ways the ones who suffer the most from it. For them, each lost sale or stream is a direct hit to their paycheck.
Challenges Faced by Indie Musicians
For independent musicians, music sales and streams are the lifeblood for making a career possible. Piracy more immediately cuts into their revenues, eroding their ability to invest in recording new music, touring, and working to develop their artistry. Unlike established artists with large fan bases and diverse income streams, indie musicians are particularly vulnerable to the financial losses caused by unauthorized music sharing. Zentner's study found that P2P use depresses the CD purchase probability by 30%. These longitudinal studies, which utilize individual-level survey data, find consistently negative coefficients. As a result, file sharing harms music sales.
Opportunities for Growth
Even with all these hurdles, the digital age opens new doors for indie artists. Platforms like Bandcamp and Patreon allow them to connect directly with fans, sell music and merchandise, and receive financial support. Social media and OTT platforms give you new opportunities to introduce yourself to new viewers and grow your own community. Adopt these tools — but more than anything else, invest in creating a connected community. By taking advantage of these tools, independent artists can effectively address piracy and prosper in the digital music ecosystem.
The Evolution of Music Piracy Post-Napster
Napster’s end didn’t stop music piracy – it just shifted in shape. Compounding the issue, new file-sharing services came online, and new forms of unauthorized music distribution quickly developed. Among the most alarming trends is the proliferation of “fake artists” on streaming platforms.
Emergence of Fake Artists
Fake artists are just what they sound like—tracks uploaded to streaming services under the artist name of generic (or, often, completely made-up) artists. These tracks are actually just a conveyor belt of thin, copyright infringing music made to game the system and create streams to make money. Just three music piracy sites were responsible for more than 80% of the overall revenue lost by the Top 50 websites in the UK illegally infringing on music copyright. By overwhelming the services with these tracks, the ne’er-do-wells cut into the revenue for actual creators.
The Role of Streaming Farms and Opaque Algorithms
Streaming farms, a black market practice that employs bots to manipulate stream counts, make the problem even worse. These farms game streaming algorithms in order to boost these manufactured artists. Consequently, independent and transformative artists find it harder to get seen. The challenge is that these algorithms are opaque, making it difficult to detect and combat this fraud. Unfortunately, this leaves artists with an unsettlingly uneven playing field.
Current State of Music Piracy
Though now more than ever we have legitimate music streaming services at our fingertips, music piracy continues to be a problem. The convenience and affordability of these services have certainly cut the legs out from under piracy, but they haven’t killed the threat of it outright.
Are We Still Facing Piracy Issues?
Yes, very much so. And even when people have the option to stream legally, millions still choose to pirate content but not for the reasons you think. A sizable 46% of users download music illegally mainly because they want to have it offline. Furthermore, 37% of users think they should not be required to pay for each song separately. Unlicensed music still remains a large and ever-present threat. In the 2017 Digital Music Report from the International Federation of the Phonographic Industry (IFPI), it was reported that 23% of individuals surveyed are currently using stream-ripping services. The number of users switching to public torrent sites during the quarantine grew in places like the U.S. (15%), India (23-43%), the UK (18.53%), Canada (17.5%), and EU (26.44%).
Low Royalty Rates and Their Impact
Perhaps the most significant driver behind this ongoing piracy is the widespread belief that artists are not fairly paid by streaming platforms. The low royalty rates from these platforms have been a source of frustration for many musicians. This removes an important option for them to make a living from their music. Other listeners may sense injustice and resort to piracy in protest. Others might interpret it as an effort to ensure greater financial support goes directly to artists.
Future Challenges in the Music Industry
The music industry is always changing though, and new technologies and business models keep appearing. How they adapt to all of this and what sustainable revenue models are will be key to the industry’s future.
Adapting to New Technologies
Between AI-generated music and the expanding capabilities of blockchain technology, these forces could upend the music industry and open new doors. Thanks to AI, we can produce more original music than ever before at a blistering pace. Beyond the hype, it raises important questions about copyright and artistic ownership. We all know that blockchain technology is extremely promising. It can help build smarter, more open, fairer systems for distributing capital to and monetizing music. As the industry adopts these technologies, they should engage with the ethical and legal implications.
Finding Sustainable Revenue Models
The previous paradigm of music sales and streaming has been upended time and again. Our industry needs to focus on creative revenue generation. Revenue streams range from direct-to-fan support, to live streamed concerts, to behind-the-scenes content. By diversifying their revenue sources and engaging directly with fans, artists can build more sustainable careers and reduce their reliance on traditional intermediaries.
Concluding Thoughts on Music Piracy and Profits
The arc of music sharing has gone from piracy to protection to profit. That evolution has been anything but smooth, characterized by years of litigation, technological disruption, and rapidly shifting consumer habits. Beyond honoring creators, our industry has made great strides in fighting against piracy and developing legal virtual music services. The battle goes on unabated.
The Ongoing Battle Against Piracy
The issue of music piracy is an ever-lurking adversary. The music industry needs to invest more into anti-piracy efforts and educate consumers on why it’s important that they support artists and not break copyright laws. Collaboration between rights holders, technology companies, and law enforcement agencies is critical to ensuring that the fight against online music piracy remains swift and effective.
The Future of the Music Industry
The future of the music industry depends on it embracing new technologies, not demonizing them. It needs to adopt new business models and develop an environment that honors creators and their craft. Through greater collaboration, the industry will ensure interoperability across all platforms while ultimately developing a creator-first consumer experience.
%%
